“Hackers are the new Hot-Rodders”
‘The Hack’ opinion column is written by our newest contributor to The Current, Harry Fryer. He’s the founder/CEO of Blaise Electric, and an employee/investor in the Bike Sheds Motor Co. in London
From the experts in the field, here are the obstacles, challenges and solutions required to transition to electric motorcycles, beyond purely functional urban scooters.
1. Change The User Attitude
From a user perspective, changing attitudes isn’t straightforward, as the attributes of internal-combustion (IC) motorcycling have developed for over a century. Today’s motorcyclists are accustomed to the smell of gasoline, noise, and relative mechanical and riding complexity. Getting them to accept something with characteristics that are pretty much the opposite will take time. There’s a hesitancy among riders who think ‘going electric’ means giving something up. The biggest hurdle to E-Bike ownership is actually cultural, and largely due to age demographics, and riders have grown up with. This impression of IC motorcycling will exist until the last generation to use gasoline is gone. There’s already a generational gap between riders who started out on petrol powered machines and those who’ve witnessed electric bikes as a normal option, who approach E-Bikes with an un-biased user experience and not real attachment to internal-combustion motorcycles.
2. Re-invent the “Motorcycle”
Internal-combustion motorcycles and E-Bikes are completely different species. Trying to replicate the characteristics of a gasoline motorcycle in an electric bike design does not work. By designing two-wheeled motorised electric vehicles in harmony with their components, one creates a completely different riding experience, one that is true to their nature. As more people become familiar with the technology and the unique riding experience E-Bikes offer, we’ll see whole new audiences get on board, and from then the growth will explode. The responsibility for that change lies with the manufactures. They have to resist the habit to do what’s always been done [ie, ‘gas tanks’ on E-Bikes – ed.], and show customers what we have not even imagined. The motorcycle industry is entering one of the most consequential disruptions of transportation in history. While E-Bikes have been around for a very long time [Read our E-Bike History here], the latest batteries make possible the biggest change in propulsion technology in 130 years. We are witnessing a reinvention of the motorcycle, the engagement of new audiences, and a total industry refresh.
3. Society, Law and Regulation
Current regulations are far behind the rapid development of two-wheeled EVs, and in some regions, you can’t even register an electric motorcycle for the road. Electric bikes will become mainstream but that will be driven largely by governments and regulations. In China, the adoption of E-Bikes (mostly E-Scooters) was essentially forced in the past 10 years, and thus China leads the world in E-Bike adoption. Regardless, because of their simplicity, E-BIkes are already become one of the most frequently used vehicles for short-haul urban transportation. And in the long view, If motorcycles continue to exist, they must abandon combustion engines [at least until hydrogen or hydro power becomes viable – ed]. In 2030 we’ll see the end of gasoline vehicle sales in Europe, and California will stop selling gas-powered vehicles even sooner. Although we can’t categorically state that electric is the future of transport, we can definitely say that gasoline power isn’t. We are likely only at the beginning of seeing motive power alternatives, and electric may end up being a ‘bridge technology’ as we transition to something even more efficient.
On the regulation front, it’s often overlooked that the licensing process to ride a motorcycle. In Europe and especially the UK, is time consuming and complicated, which disincentivises new riders. We have an opportunity to re-write the licensing book today, tailored to electric motorcycles, as electric bikes don’t require the same testing methods. In short, we need a new category of motorcycle license.
4. Tech, Cost and Battery Advancement
The biggest hurdles in tech are cost, range and weight.
Range is often used as a shorthand to trash E-Bikes. There’s a sense of anxiety around where to get to your next charge, if you’re away from home. For the majority of riders who ride in urban areas, it’s a non-issue. But for longer distances, only improvements in battery technology, charging technology, energy density and infrastructure will make range anxiety a non-issue.
Currently it costs manufactures two to three times the cost of an internal combustion motor to build an electric powertrain. That drives the price of the vehicle up, and it’s why so many companies struggle to turn a profit in this segment. Either they match prices for the category and sacrifice their profit margin, or build a super-expensive bike and only sell a few to those who can afford them. The cost comes down to volume, and electric bike companies aren’t producing high enough volumes to bring down unit part prices, making them more expensive than IC engines.
Another challenge is weight versus range; the bigger the battery, the farther you can go, but at the cost of weight. With current lithium-cell technology, the ‘range per pound’ just doesn’t match gasoline, but that could change with solid-state battery technology. It’s still in its infancy, but cells have been developed that are half the size of current lithium cells and store 10 times the capacity, delivering loads more range. This kind of advancement could lead to motorcycles that are lighter and more powerful than we’ve ever seen.
5. Upgraded Infrastructure
In a late-Capitalist society, the government doesn’t provide and enhance electrical infrastructure; it’s the place of businesses, and major equity firms are currently investing in nationwide and international chains of EV charging stations. We’ve seen governments and transport lobbyists push EVs as greener transport, but as far as motorcycling goes the discussion on how people will recharge their machines is left out. A great advantage of petrol over electric is the refill time. Current level 1 and level 2 charging stations still take too long, and require trip planning and extra time. DC fast chargers are becoming increasingly more efficient and provide a much shorter charge time. However, there are not enough fast chargers available for the consequential demand, and until E-Bikes become more popular, they won’t swing the needle on support for fast charging stations.
1) ” From a user perspective, changing attitudes isn’t straightforward ”
FALSE ! It isn’t about changing attitudes … its about making the damn things function
2) ” Internal-combustion motorcycles and E-Bikes are completely different species”
Blatantly to the point of ludicrousness FALSE .Be it ICE Steam E/V Turbine et al ad nauseam … a freaking motorcycle is a motorcycle … and therefor should be expected to function as a motorcycle ( Semantics and Philosophy 101 for dummies ). So much for revisionist idiocracy
3) ” Current regulations are far behind the rapid development of two-wheeled EVs, and in some regions, you can’t even register an electric motorcycle for the road.”
Total BS on the best of days . There is nowhere in the continental US AK or Hawaii where an EV M/C cannot be registered licensed and ridden legally ( trust me … the Fed wife confirmed that thru her contacts in the DOT )
4) ” Range is often used as a shorthand to trash E-Bikes. There’s a sense of anxiety around where to get to your next charge, if you’re away from home. For the majority of riders who ride in urban areas, it’s a non-issue. ”
Absolute BS plain and simple . Reality is there is NOWHERE on the planet where recharging is not an issue ( DW .. NordNews etc et al ad nauseam ) Try doing a bit of research before sticking yer foot in it
5) ” In a late-Capitalist society, the government doesn’t provide and enhance electrical infrastructure; it’s the place of businesses, and major equity firms are currently investing in nationwide and international chains of EV charging stations.”
This is total BS on so many levels one’d need an entire website to reveal the actual facts … but here’s a few ;
a) We are in an Anarcho Capitalist society … not ‘ late ‘
b) All carbon based fuels and energy etc are fully subsidized by federal governments ( our oil and coal industry is second only to the military in federal subsidies )
c) Therefore the ONLY way EV infrastructure will succeed is with federal dollars . Though in reality even in those countries currently subsidizing the EV economy … it isn’t … because ;
OF A LACK OF STANDARDIZED CHARGING PORTS / STATIONS AND REQUIREMENTSs by the idiots manufacturing EV’s
In other words … the EV industry is shooting itself in the foot
In conclusion .. once again … I dare you to confront me on anything I’ve said .. with clear , verifiable and authentic FACTS … rather than EV agenda based rhetoric and effluence
Please .. I’m in the mood for a good debate / argument .
In addendum to the above on how the EV transportation industry is shooting ITSELF in the foot while making vain attempts at claiming ‘ victimhood ‘
Price … oh … y’all don’t dare mention price now … do ya ?
The fact that every EV on the market …two wheels or four… is up to or exceeding double the price of its nearest ICE counterpart
The fact that every EV manufacture in the last thirty days has increased its already excessive prices for what amounts to over priced useless toys .. by 5-15% .. plus
The fact that replacement batteries for all EV’s are ludicrously priced ( a TESLA S’s will cost you $20k plus ) … and if you think the battery costs are high .. wait til you get the labor bill to change them out … along with the disposal bill …
And thats just scratching the surface when it comes to price .
Then … there’s the major issue of .. AVAILABILITY ! Just gotta have that brandy spankin new Cadillac EV or H-D LiveWire ? Yeah well … good luck with that .. cause you’ll be ordering it .. and lucky to actually receive it in 24 months … or more
And need we even go down the road of the strain EV’s are already placing on an over burdened and over stretched electrical grid ? Not to mention the head on losing battle with heavily government subsidized to the hilt Big Oil ?
So yeah … all you EV Sycophants Shills and Propagandists … get off your pathetic BLAME GAME ( oh boohoo you ) platform … and start looking inward as to why the EV market is stumbling like a wounded duck in a tar pit
Simple fact is .. the EV industry is full to the brim with pie in the sky inept nerds without so much as a modicum of business acumen ( please … TESLA is still losing $1million plus every 30 days ) unable to put together a ;
Functioning
Sustainable
Viable
Practical
Intelligent
Well engineered
Quality manufactured
Common sense product and business strategy
Preferring to pursue NIMBY mentality , Bells&Whistles engineering ( over substance ) , BS marketing , blatant lies ..extremely opaque financial practices ( even to its investors ) placing ( personal ) profit above all else .
Which is … if’n ya’d bother to look up the term … the very definition of
Anarcho – Capitalism ….the very epitome of Ayn Rand ideology ..
Cause brothers and sisters … we passed ‘ late ‘ capitalism in the 80’s … left ‘hyper ‘ capitalism in the dust two decades ago … now in the depths of the very thing that is already proving to be our ” Road to Perdition ”
And in the end … as stated … it’s the EV Industry shooting itself in the foot . Quite well in fact .
Good enthusiasm, and thank you for reading the article. EV’s aren’t for everyone, but you’re welcome to your own opinion. We write articles like this to create discussion, so thank you for your personal view.
Best
Harry
I love a boxing match that finished like a bar room brawl. I don’t love the article but I get it. I don’t dig the tone of the responses it’s brought forward, but I get it.
I can’t really disagree with any of it.
It’s because right now there really are two sides to the coin, the hyper optimistic and the “come on we are way to smart to have the wool pulled over our eyes because you said so” crowd. If I had to reduce it down to one of the biggest issues with what’s happening in emotos and their future it’s this, please just freaking be honest with me about how far I can ride! Don’t give me the common avoidance that “it all depends how you ride”, let’s just make it simple and I’ll plan around that. But how do we make it simple?
Okay, to every emoto company out there now and in the future take notes:
Pick an average weight and run the bike at 30mph until it goes into limp mode, jot down the mileage. Keep going up in 10 mph increments until you hit the top posted speed limit, then make a chart from the data and/or pick an average speed and use that as a fair starting point for me to understand what I’m buying into. Why is it so hard for new emoto companies just to be honest, it’s a curve as we get better motors and batteries as well as charging times, we aren’t children, we’ll get it and it might not stop all of us from buying when we compare your stats to your price. And can we put some time into simply standardizing three battery sizes across the board of every emoto compan where batteries can be plug and play, literally. And it would be nice if we could use the same charger instead of this whole iPhone update cord, old cord, google phone cord and whatever else companies come up with just so we have to buy their cord after dropping an already inflated amount of cash on their product.
This is very interesting, and thanks for taking the time to read the article. I do think there’s absolutely a lack of trust when it comes to e-moto brands and consumers. It’s a new space and salesman are trying to convince motorists that EV’s are just as practical/efficient as IC’s. As you quite rightly mentioned the stats don’t always measure up to reality when it comes to range and this puts consumers off. Until EV’s can proactively match their counterparts they’re another method of transport for specific uses.
The motorcycle was invented when someone bolted an engine onto a bicycle frame. History is repeating itself. I am seeing electric bicycles becoming more and more motorcycle-like, but on their own terms, without the dead weight of expectations created by a century of ICE motorcycles.
Manufacturers of electric motorcycles who are positioning their products as a one-for-one replacement for the ICE motorcycle are likely to go down in history as a transitional phase. It is what develops out of the electric bicycle that will end up as the new motorcycle.
Like vinyl to Spotify this is a long conversation with many rightly held opinion. We are very much in a transition period from on form to another, without leaving the original behind. There are many things talkative are changing all at the same time and picking through the bones of this in a dozen or so years will expose some insightful predictions and some that just never made it past the mass market starting line like Mini disc….now there’s a debate.
I enjoyed the read and the expressed input and opinion. I like the idea that history is once again repeating itself and the pinions are as well.